Real Estate Statistics
| Average Price | $1.3M |
|---|---|
| Lowest Price | $49.5K |
| Highest Price | $6.9M |
| Total Listings | 10 |
| Avg. Price/SQFT | $167 |
Property Types (active listings)
Search Tilloo Cay Real Estate Listings
- All Listings
- Under $100,000
- $100,000 - $200,000
- $200,000 - $300,000
- $300,000 - $400,000
- $400,000 - $500,000
- $700,000 - $800,000
- Over $1,000,000
What Is Tilloo Cay?
Tilloo Cay sits in the central Abacos south of Lubbers Quarters, flanked by the Sea of Abaco on the west and the Atlantic on the east. The Tilloo Cay National Park covers a large portion of the island, protecting the land and the surrounding marine environment from development. The park designation is permanent, which means the undeveloped character of most of the cay is not temporary or conditional. It is structural.
Private land exists on the portions of Tilloo Cay that fall outside the park boundary. These parcels are genuinely rare. The combination of National Park adjacency, boat-only access, and minimal existing development means that what little privately held land remains here is unlikely to increase in supply. Buyers who find a parcel on Tilloo Cay are looking at something that, by its nature, cannot be replicated.
Access is by private boat only. There is no scheduled service of any kind, no ferry dock, and no airstrip. The island sits within reasonable boating distance of Elbow Cay and Lubbers Quarters, and Marsh Harbour is accessible in under an hour in a well-found vessel. That proximity gives Tilloo Cay owners a workable connection to services and amenities without sacrificing the separation the island provides. But the boat is not optional. It is the only way on and off.
The marine environment around Tilloo Cay is among the healthiest in the Abacos, benefiting directly from the National Park protections. Snorkeling, fishing, and diving off the island access reef systems and water clarity that reflect what the Bahamas looked like before significant boat traffic and development arrived. For buyers who care about the environment, the park designation is an asset rather than a constraint.
Buying Property on Tilloo Cay
Buying on Tilloo Cay starts with a different set of questions than most real estate purchases. Before evaluating price or negotiating terms, buyers need to confirm that the parcel they are considering sits on privately held land outside the National Park boundary. This is a non-negotiable step, and a local Bahamian attorney with title search experience in Abaco is the right person to carry it out. Scott can recommend attorneys who know the Tilloo Cay land records specifically.
Existing properties on the island are few and range from raw, undeveloped lots to off-grid homes built by owners who established their presence here years ago. Off-grid infrastructure on Tilloo Cay typically means solar power, rainwater collection, and composting or holding tank waste systems. These are not exotic arrangements in the outer Bahamas, but buyers who have not owned off-grid property before should understand what maintaining those systems involves before committing.
Building on Tilloo Cay is a long-term project in the most literal sense. Materials arrive by barge. Workers travel from the mainland. The permitting process runs through standard Bahamian channels and requires patience. Buyers who succeed with this kind of project are those who have a clear vision, a realistic timeline measured in years rather than months, and a contractor relationship they trust. The outcome, for the right buyer, is a property that could not exist anywhere more accessible in the Abacos.
Tilloo Cay suits a narrow buyer profile: someone who values natural isolation above convenience, is comfortable with boat dependency and off-grid systems, and is thinking about the property as a long-term personal asset rather than a near-term income generator. If that description fits, there are very few places in the Bahamas that offer what Tilloo Cay does. If it doesn't, one of the more developed cays in the Abaco chain will likely serve you better.
Frequently Asked Questions About Tilloo Cay Real Estate
What is Tilloo Cay?
Tilloo Cay is a largely undeveloped island in the central Abacos, south of Lubbers Quarters and Elbow Cay. A significant portion of the cay falls within a protected National Park designation, leaving a small number of private properties on the remaining land. It is one of the least developed islands in the Abaco chain, accessible by private boat only, with no commercial amenities or scheduled ferry service.
What types of property are available on Tilloo Cay?
Tilloo Cay has very few private properties. Available real estate consists primarily of raw land and a small number of existing off-grid homes. This is not a market with regular listings or active inventory. Buyers interested in Tilloo Cay are typically looking for a rare land opportunity in a protected, natural setting rather than a turnkey purchase.
How do you get to Tilloo Cay?
Tilloo Cay is accessible by private boat only. There is no scheduled ferry service, no water taxi, and no airstrip. The island sits in the central Abacos within reasonable boating distance of Elbow Cay, Lubbers Quarters, and Marsh Harbour. Owning a reliable vessel is a firm requirement for anyone considering property here.
Can non-Bahamians purchase land or property on Tilloo Cay?
Yes. Foreign nationals can purchase privately held land and residential property on Tilloo Cay under the standard Bahamas foreign ownership framework. Purchases under $500,000 USD require registration with the Bahamas Investments Board after closing. Transactions at $500,000 USD and above require prior government approval. A local Bahamian attorney handles conveyancing. Buyers should also confirm that any parcel they are considering sits outside the National Park boundary before proceeding.
What are property taxes like on Tilloo Cay?
The Bahamas has no income tax, capital gains tax, or inheritance tax. An annual Real Property Tax applies to privately held land and homes. Owner-occupied properties valued up to $300,000 USD are fully exempt. Values between $300,000 and $500,000 USD are taxed at 0.625%, and amounts above $500,000 USD are taxed at 1% on the excess. Vacant land follows its own assessment schedule. Confirm all applicable rates with your attorney before completing any purchase.